Storey's in the Dirt

Regenerative Farming & Food Sovereignty

How to Select the Right Tomato Varieties for Your Garden

How to Select the Right Tomato Varieties for Your Garden

by Teri Storey3 min read
TomatoesGarden Planning

## Tomatoes | Part 1 When you grow your own tomatoes, variety matters. The right tomato for your garden depends on your climate, soil, growing space, and culinary goals. This guide will help you choose wisely so you can enjoy bountiful harvests and delicious meals. ### Heirloom vs. Hybrid vs. Open...

Share:

Tomatoes | Part 1

When you grow your own tomatoes, variety matters. The right tomato for your garden depends on your climate, soil, growing space, and culinary goals. This guide will help you choose wisely so you can enjoy bountiful harvests and delicious meals.

Heirloom vs. Hybrid vs. Open-Pollinated

Heirloom: These are old, stable varieties passed down through generations. They offer rich, complex flavors and unique colors and shapes. However, they can be more prone to disease.

Hybrid: These are cross-bred for traits like disease resistance, uniformity, and productivity. Great choice for reliable yields, but may lack the nuanced flavors of heirlooms.

Open-Pollinated: These breed true from seed and allow for seed saving. Many heirlooms are open-pollinated, but not all open-pollinated varieties are heirloom.

Determinate vs. Indeterminate

Determinate: These grow to a set height and produce most of their fruit over a few weeks. Ideal for container gardening or for growers who want a concentrated harvest for canning.

Indeterminate: These continue growing and producing fruit all season. Best for gardeners who want a continuous fresh supply of tomatoes.

Match Varieties to Climate and Soil

  • Hot climates: Look for heat-tolerant varieties such as 'Heatmaster' or 'Phoenix.'

  • Short seasons: Choose early producers like 'Stupice' or 'Siberian.'

  • Humid regions: Opt for disease-resistant varieties to combat fungal issues.

Test your soil and amend it as needed. Tomatoes thrive in well-drained, fertile soil with a pH of 6.0-6.8.

Flavor and Intended Use

  • Fresh eating: 'Brandywine,' 'Cherokee Purple,' 'Sun Gold'

  • Canning and sauces: 'Roma,' 'San Marzano,' 'Amish Paste'

  • Drying: 'Principe Borghese,' 'Juliet'

On my own farm this season, I’m growing a mix of beloved slicers, heirlooms, and experimental lines — including Pink Brandywine, Kellogg’s Breakfast, Dragon’s Eye, Porkchop (my most popular variety), and Barry’s Crazy Cherry. I also run small breeding projects each year to stabilize certain varieties, like a Pink Heart Extra Large and Cherry Bundles. I always recommend that growers plant a few tried-and-true tomatoes alongside at least one new-to-you variety — it keeps the garden exciting and builds knowledge over time.

A Few More Tips

  • Grow a mix! This gives you a variety of flavors and harvest times.

  • Save seeds from your favorites.

  • Keep a garden journal to track what performs well each season.

In Part 2, we’ll cover how to start tomato seeds for strong, healthy plants. Stay tuned and happy gardening!

[ { "type": "highlight", "id": "1be1bef4-c19c-4aef-8c4f-ac21b7f8d7b5", "shape": "underlineCurve", "isFront": false, "isAnimationEnabled": false, "animation": "draw", "duration": 0.5, "direction": "right", "color": { "type": "THEME_COLOR" }, "thickness": { "unit": "em", "value": 0.1 }, "linecap": "square" } ]

2025 GROWING SEASON

🍅 What’s Growing on My Farm This Year
Here’s my current tomato lineup — a mix of favorites, flavor tests, and breeding projects:

Classic / Market Favorites

  • Pink Brandywine

  • Pink Beefsteak

  • Yellow Beefsteak

  • Beefsteak

Specialty / Heirloom / Flavor Showcase

  • Kellogg’s Breakfast

  • Dad’s Sunset

  • Genosova

  • Porkchop

  • Dragon’s Eye

Experimental Lines (future production)

  • Mottle Boar

  • Pink Heart Extra Large

  • Perfect Heart

Cherry / Small Fruit Tomatoes

  • Black Cherry

  • German Lunch Box

  • Barry’s Crazy Cherry

  • Cherry Bundles (cluster-fruiting test)

! Summer time and livings easy :) Summer time and livings easy :) [/caption]

Part of the Tomato Growing Guide Series

A 3-part series

Where to Go Next

📖Next Start Here

Dance Partners in the Garden

## The Art of Companion Planting Companion planting is one of the simplest and most effective ways to boost your garden’s health and productivity. Whether you’re growing vegetables, herbs, or flowers, understanding why certain plants thrive together can unlock a deeper connection with your garden. ...

Vegetable GardeningGarden Planning
Read more →
🔍Dig Deeper

Transplanting Tomatoes and Early Season Care

## Tomatoes | Part 3 You’ve babied your seedlings and watched them grow strong — now it’s time to send them out into the big wide world of your garden beds. Transplanting is a critical stage. Get it right, and you’ll set your tomatoes up for a season of healthy growth and abundant fruit. ### Timin...

TomatoesTomatoes
Read more →
🌱Related Content

How to Start Tomato Seeds for Strong, Healthy Plants

## Tomatoes | Part 2 Starting tomatoes from seed is one of the most satisfying steps in the growing process. With a little planning and the right conditions, you can raise robust, vibrant plants that thrive in your garden or containers. Here's how to do it right from the start. ### Know Your Timin...

TomatoesTomatoes
Read more →